Category Archives: Review

Some Unusual Dunbarton Tobacco and Trust Cigars

I’m never one to chase after Dunbarton Tobacco and Trusts store exclusives, or rare stuff, but I had a couple things fall into my lap recently, so I figured I’d dedicate a blog post to them.  The first two are thanks to Kevin at CigarProp. I asked him to purchase a couple of the Black Angus for me when he went to the launch event at Corona Cigar in Tampa, not even knowing how damn expensive they are, and he sent me two from his box.  I’m not even sure why this cigar caught my interest, I’m not really a fan of the FSG tobacco, and I certainly don’t seek out $30 cigars, but I was intrigued. Steve Saka doesn’t seem to care for the tobacco, and I needed  to see how he would come up with a Saka-worthy cigar.  This theme will repeat itself, by the way.  So Kevin sent me the cigars, even put them in a box autographed by Steve, which put me into shock until I opened to box and there were just the two cigars in there. I smoked one, and it was good.  You probably want specifics!  This is a 6¼” x 54 with a box press and a pigtail (I believe Saka calls this a “colita”) cap.  In addition to the Florida Sun Grown Corojo ’99 tobacco, it has a Ecuador Habano Viso Rosado wrapper, San Andrés binder (the “Cultivo Tonto” tobacco used for the wrapper of the Sin Compromiso) and a Nicaragua “Angelica” Criollo filler.  I took notes, and said that it started out with a twang, and this was before I read the description mentioning “twang” so it really is there.  It’s a meaty cigar, savory, delicious with that twang, maybe it’s the Black Angus branding that made me think of meat?  It’s good, I’m really fortunate to have been able to try this, because dropping that kind of coin on a cigar isn’t something I’d do. It’s a special occasion cigar, for sure. I’d wager Kevin really enjoys this as he’s an FSG fan.

 

Another cigar that I wouldn’t have had a chance to sample were it not for Kevin’s generosity was the Candela lancero out of the #GFY (Good For You, so Saka claims, be we know what it really means!) sampler.  I tossed around the idea of buying a box, but the thought of smoking ten lanceros that were all different, none of which were regular production and may never see the light of day again didn’t appeal to me.  Apparently someone sent Kevin a couple knowing he likes Candela and he shared one with me. This is another leaf that Saka doesn’t like, in a format he doesn’t like. I maintain that I was the one who put the candela lancero idea in his head, evidenced by this audio snippet:

He seemed to poopoo the idea he’d ever make one, then back peddle a little.  Anyway, this is a traditional 7″ x 38 lancero with the pigtail cap. This was a nice smoke, not at all mild (think RomaCraft Fomorian),  with the grassy tartness one gets from a good candela wrapper.  I had to relight a few times, but I was probably smoking it too slow, as I’m careful not to overheat lanceros by smoking too fast.  I’m sure the other nine cigars in the sampler are excellent, Steve doesn’t put crap out with his name on it.  This was special to me since I claim responsibility!  Thanks again Kevin! 

 

My final cigar in this week’s tribute to Dunbarton was the Stillwell Star Aromatic No. 22. This was included in a media package last month.  The Stillwell series is unique in that id incorporates pipe tobacco in the blends. We drove to South Carolina for the release event at Low Country Cigar and Pipe where I picked up a sampler of the originals.  I didn’t smoke any there because I wanted to get the right experience, not in a room full of other people smoking.  “Room Note” is an important part of the Stillwell experience, in my opinion.  Now, I don’t smoke a pipe, too much fidgeting for me, but I have, and I have pretty detailed memories of my first dentist smoking a pipe.  He was a one man show, he’d put his pipe on his desk, do whatever he had to do in your mouth, then light it up afterwards while he wrote up the bill (there was a cash price and an insurance price).  I think I went to him from the time I had teeth until I was in my 20s.  So this Aromatic No. 22 is a 6″ x 52 parejo, with a  Ecuadorian habano wrapper, Mexican San Andrés negro binder with a filler blend that includes Cavendish burley and Virginia pipe tobaccos. This was originally the Holiday 2022, just rebanded with the blue Stilwell dress.  I can’t say that I fully appreciate the pipe tobacco blends, but it’s an enjoyable cigar. It has the “pipey” flavors that my pedestrian palate can identify, and the room note is distinctly “pipey”. I almost wish this had the sweet cap, like the Aromatic No 1.  There’s a little bit of a drying sensation I get. I enjoyed this while watching hockey on the porch, hard to go wrong there.  Burn and draw were exceptional, and this is a nice change of pace.  I still have a set o the original four blends, I suspect I’ll have to resample them one of these days. 

 

That’s all for today. I thought about smoking a Mi Querida PataPerro, but it was a little too cold last night for a 3 hour cigar! I’ll save those for warm weather.  That’s all for today, until the next time, 

 

CigarCraig

😃+
Share

1 Comment

Filed under Review

Cigars from Nestor Miranda, Joya de Nicaragua, Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust and Foundation

I ended up smoking some pretty great cigars over the last few days!  I started off with the Nestor Miranda Grand Reserve 2024. I have memory of smoking the 2011 and 2012 versions, which were the only other two previously released. The 2024 was released in celebration of Miami Cigar and Company‘s 35th anniversary.  It’s a 6 1/8″ x 52 torpedo, made at the My Father factory in Esteli, and is a Nicaraguan Puro.  This is an absolutely delicious cigar. It started with an interesting spice, maybe like nutmeg, very intriguing. It had a really nice desert cigar feel to it, like smoking a pie. I thought it was really good.  Thanks to Gabe Pińeres for sending me this.  Super-yummy.

 

Next up was the Joya de Nicaragua Cinco de Cinco. I know this one has been around for a while, but one came into my possession at the the Florida Barn Smoker last month.  This was the Corona Extra vitola, 6 ¼” x 46 with a pigtail cap.  Cinco de Cinco seems to translate to “5 out of 5”, but I want to say it has something to do with the company’s 55th anniversary.  I think this is my favorite cigar out of the Obras Maestros collection, and there are some great cigars in that collection.  I have to say that it’s really hard to pick a favorite, Numero Uno, Cinco Decadas, Cuatro Cinco, now this one?  What a line up!  This one  has a San Andrés wrapper, with Nicaraguan fillers and binder.  Burn and draw were outstanding, and it was loaded with dark chocolate flavors, and I loved it.  It’s definitely one I’ll be revisiting.  For someone who loves dark chocolate, but has to severely limit my intake because it triggers migraines for me, this is an acceptable substitute!

 

Yesterday, while watching hockey, I smoked the newest size in Dunbarton Tobacco and Trust‘s Sin Compromiso line, the Selección No. 4, a 5″ x 54 soft box pressed robusto.  This is another San Andrès wrapper, this one Saka calls “Cultivo Tonto” which has the farmer removes all bet the best leaves from the plant so that they get the most nutrients. This make the tobacco more expensive, of course, because there’s no lower quality leaves to subsidise the better leaves.  Saka only ever uses the best and most expensive materials anyway, right?  I absolutely love the No. 5, which is a Toro, so I was excited to try the robusto.  This was a really good cigar, although I felt like it wasn’t quite as sophisticated as the larger size.  Sure, it was better than a lot of cigars, had some earth and black coffee notes, but it just seemed less refined.  If I can afford it, I’ll pick another one up one day. 

 

Finally, I smoked a cigar that Stace Berkland sent me a bit ago.  I may have mentioned before that Stace had sent me some cigars in an unexpected reciprocation for some things I sent him. Here’s the silliness: Stace wanted to purchase one of my 20 year old plastic cutters, the little rectangular ones that Saka’s über expensive Guillotino de Saka is based off of.  I had a few that’s I’ve had for years, used to buy them at my local shop, the guys there called it the “hot knife through butter cutter”. Like I said, I have had three of these for 20+ years, I’ve got a load of cutters, sending one to a friend wasn’t a problem!  He felt the need to retaliate, so he sent some nice cigars.  One of them was this Foundation Cigars Grasshopper, which appears to be from an exclusive box from Small Batch Cigars.  This box had six of the Candella Grasshoppers, six of the Maduro, and one barber pole version.  I had never seen this cigar before, but my first thought was that it was from Foundation, something about the look of the band.  This is a small, box pressed torpedo, 5¼” x 52, with a San Andrés wrapper, Jalapa binder and fillers from Jalapa and Esteli.  This was another great smoke with some spice and dark cocoa.  Burn was excellent and I really dug it. Thanks Stace!  

 

I need to start getting my Secret Santa gift together, names went out and it’s too late to join!  I gave plenty of notice.  I”ve got my work cut out for me this time!  That’s all for today, until the next time, 

 

CigarCraig

😃+
Share

1 Comment

Filed under Review

Foxtail Cigars from Fox Cigars

As you can see by the graphic on the left side of my page, Fox Cigar has an exclusive series of cigars in the “economy” space, the Foxtail.  I’ve been working with the folks at Fox for several years, and have featured a few of their exclusives, notably the Araposa Negra and Blanca made by Black Label Trading Co.  These were exceptional, I especially liked the Negra, which, sadly, doesn’t appear to be available any more.  I should pick up some Blancas, if I do, I’ll add another Foxtail sampler.  The Foxtail comes in five varieties, and all of them have a shaggy foot and a foxtail shaped flag on the head.  They come in three sizes, although I have to wonder a little about who came up with the names.  They are Robusto, Toro and Gordo.  I know, you’re thinking “they sound like perfectly reasonable names!”, but the Robusto is 6″x50, the Toro is 7″ x 54 and the Gordo is 7″ x 60. Perhaps they are measuring from where the wrapper starts, as they all have a 1″ unfinished foot.  No problem, I rarely smoke anything shorter than six inches.  Here are some short recaps on each one:

 

I started with the Corojo Toro (the sampler is only offered in the 7″ x 54 “Toro”). This has a Sungrown Nicaraguan Corojo wrapper, over a Nicaraguan binder with Nicaraguan, Costa Rican and Colombian fillers. Where these are made, nor whether these are long or mixed fill was shared with me.  At this price, they almost have to be mixed, but they all burned properly like a long fill cigar.  This Corojo has the hint of white sugar I find lately in cigars tagged as Corojo.  It wasn’t bad, decent tobacco flavor with a bit of a spice.

 

Next up was the Maduro Toro (I know, I usually lead with the maduro, I changed it up this time. Also worth mentioning that I smoked these on different days. Those of you who follow on IG or Facebook will already know this.). This one also has the Sungrown Nicaraguan Corojo wrapper, with a Nicaraguan binder and Nicaraguan and Costa Rican fillers. This one had some subtle cocoa and spice with some tobacco, nothing overpowering, just a nice cigar and a good value.

 

I followed with the Barber Pole, which is, I believe both fermentations of the aforementioned Corojo and Maduro wrappers. Sungrown Nicaraguan Corojo wrapper, with a Nicaraguan binder and Nicaraguan and Costa Rican fillers. Honestly, I don’t know if in a blindfolded scenario I could choose between this and the Corojo, they were remarkably similar.  The aesthetics of the dual wrappers is nice, and doesn’t take anything away from the burn and draw. It lacks the Columbian tobacco that’s in the Corojo, maybe that’s what adds the subtle spice that I didn’t get in this one.

 

I went into the Sweet Tip with some concerns, which ended up to be unfounded. This has an Ecuador Connecticut wrapper, Nicaraguan  binder and Nicaraguan and Columbian fillers. The wrapper is a darker shade than the Connecticut.The sweetness on the cap was minimal, it added nicely to the flavor of the cigar.  Some sweet capped cigars can be too much, not this one. It had the approximate sweetness on the lips as a Sobremesa Brulee.  I say that to be funny, but I hardly noticed that it was there. This might actually be my favorite of the quintet.  It has some bready bakery notes, some spice and that subtle sweetness.  I liked this one.

 

Finally I smoked the Connecticut, which has the exact same makeup as the Sweet Tip. This might be my second favorite of the bunch for me, which is weird if you’ve followed me for any stretch of time and see a pattern of what I like.  It was smooth, with the same bakery, spice and less of the sweetness of the Sweet Tip.  All in all, this is a nice line of cigars. The tail on the head (mine were all lying flat,  looked like a messy cap job until further inspection), the shaggy foot that doesn’t burn holes in your shirt, and all five having different bands to differentiate between them in cases where it’s not fairly evident, sets these apart from other similarly priced offerings. Thanks to the folks at Fox Cigar for sending these, like I said, I have no problem adding some on to my next order. I really need to get to Arizona to visit one of their lounges one of these days.  

 

That’s all for now. I hope everyone had a good Thanksgiving.  Now it’s time to get ready for Christmas. There’s still time to get in on the CigarCraig.com Secret Santa!  Maybe next week I’ll feature some new lighters that have come into my possession. Until the next time, 

 

CigarCraig

 

😃+
Share

2 Comments

Filed under Review

Villiger, West Tampa and La Flor de Dulzura Cigars, and Some New Accessories

It’s getting into the busy time of year, and I seem to have a bunch of stuff to write about suddenly! Not a complaint, I’m thankful, as s appropriate this time of year.  Don’t forget to sign up for the CigarCraig.com Secret Santa. There’s a small, but very high quality, group signed up, it’s been a lot of fun in the past.  I smoked some new-to-me cigars this week, a couple of which are new to everyone.  First off is the Villiger TAA 2024.  Villager likes to make their TAA cigars in a different factory every year,  2020 was made by E.P. Carillo, ’21 at La Palma, ’22 at La Zona and 2023 at Aganorsa (the only one of the bunch I haven’t smoked).  This one is made in Honduras at the Maya Selva factory.  Maya Selva is a relatively unknown brand in the U.S., but is huge in Europe.  It’s a shame too, because they are really good cigars! I spoke with Maya at the 2016 IPCPR show and again at the 2020 TPE. This cigar is a Honduran Puro, is a solid medium in strength, and surprised me with a prominent white sugar flavor.  I was impressed to the point where I smoked another one yesterday. I will keep an eye out at my local TAA store for these.  Very nice.

 

When I was in Tampa a couple weeks ago I ran into Ricky Rodriguez of West Tampa Tobacco at the Tampa Corona Cigars location where he was doing an event.  I actually didn’t run into him, I had texted him about meeting up while I was there and he said he was doing an event at the store.  He gave me a couple of his new Circle of Life cigars, which I don’t think are in stores yet.  This is a cigar made by Ernesto Carillo at his Casa Carillo factory in the D.R. Ricky and Ernesto have a history, as Rick was on “Team La Gloria” before he took over CAO at General Cigars. The blend on this is undisclosed.  The wrapper is dark and oily, and not so pretty. I gor a strong, cloying licoricey flavor, it was pungent, and I liked it. I would have enjoyed it more if it had burned better, some more humidor time might help.  This was definitely an interesting cigar, unlike anything else in the WTT portfolio, which is good, I’ll smoke more of these when available.

 

Another cigar I picked up in Tampa was the La Flor de Dulzura Maduro in a toro size. I took a few minutes to walk up and down 7th Street in Ybor and wandered into King Corona, which is one of the more well known shops there.  They had a well appointed humidor, and I picked up one of their house brand cigars. I should have gotten a selection, but I was travelling light, and didn’t have much travel humidor space. If I remember correctly, these are made at Tabacos de Costa Rica, the factory that makes Atabey, Byron, Bandelero, LVH, and I think Vegas de Santiago.  This was a really well made cigar, and had some of the sweet cocoa and subtle spice I expect from a maduro cigar. It was very nice, worth the $12.  If you find yourself in Tampa take a walk through Ybor City and stop in King Corona, I imagine it’s quite the hopping place in the evenings! 

 

I recently corresponded with the folks at Your Elegant Bar about their products. Initially I thought they were just another company selling Prestige Import Group stuff (which is great stuff, I own a cabinet from them, and their retail arm, First Class Humidors was one of my first advertisers), but I was mistaken. They sell a brand called Lubinsky, and sent me a travel humidor, lighter and punch to have a look at. First, there’s the punch they call the Nutzen M1- Cigar Needle And Punch Tool. This handy tool has a 10mm punch which retracts and extends with a twist. It also unscrews to reveal a pair of tines, presumably to skewer your cigar to get the most out of it. I admit to routinely using such a tool, although mine has much shorter tines. These are about 20mm long, which is almost exactly 50 ring gauge, so one must be careful using this on smaller ring cigars.  I find that a 10mm punch is large enough for some smaller ring cigars (under 50), but I prefer my 13mm punch for most cigars.  Actually, I prefer a V or straight cut, but some cigars need to be punched, and it’s a handy thing to have on the key ring.  

 

The lighter they sent was the Margo 3 flame lighter in copper.  This is a nice cylindrical lighter about 4″ long and probably 62 ring gauge.  The jets seem to be slightly pointed inwards to make a pointed flame.  It has a large fuel window in the back, and an 8mm punch in the bottom. The adjustment wheel is fairly easy to move with a fingernail, although I rather use a Swiss Army knife screwdriver. I have had cheap torch lighters for nearly 20 years, and fairly expensive ones that crap out in a year or two, so we’ll see how this holds up. I religiously purge my lighters whenever I refill them, which I believe extends their life.  The one thing I have trouble getting used to on this one is that the ignition button slides up (there’s an arrow!), which is counter to every lighter I’ve ever had. It makes it a little awkward for me.

 

Finally,The Gator-Effect Travel Humidor, also carrying the Lubinsky brand name. This has two spanish cedar trays, with velcro straps to keep your cigars from rolling around. The bottom accommodates longer cigars (there’s a two slot tray that I removed to accomodate a Boveda and a hygrometer for testing), and the top tray will hold up to about a toro.  Total capacity is 18 cigars, eight on the bottom and ten on top. I loaded it up and it’s been holding the right humidity perfectly. I wouldn’t much bother with humidification if I’m travelling, unless I’m going to a very dry location.

This is a fancy looking unit in green alligator, I’ll admit I’m more of a Pelican case kind of guy.  It does work well, although the “hinge” is a little tight, it doesn’t stay open by itself, which is only problematic if you’re going for a cigar in the bottom tray.  Maybe it’ll break in, I’m afraid to force it too much. I have half a dozen travel humidors, and I use them infrequently, although I am going to store some cigars in this one and keep monitoring it. Not sure if it’s something I’d carry with me though.  It works, and if it fits your style, go for it. 

 

That’s way more than enough for today. Happy Thanksgiving to the American readers!  Until the next time, 

 

CigarCraig

😃+
Share

2 Comments

Filed under Accessories, Review

A Special Blackbird Cigar and Some New Macanudos

I had the opportunity to purchase some cigars a few weeks in advance of their release thanks to Tyler Caldwell at Smokingpipes.com.  I met Tyler a few years ago at the Stillwell Star release event at Low Country Pipe & Cigars in South Carolina.  I hung out with him again at the last PCA show I attended, super nice dude.  He had a hand in blending the new Blackbird Cigars Flamingo, which is a Smokingpipes.com exclusive.  You may recall that Smokingpipes.com (Low Country is their retail outlet) is owned by Laudisi Enterprises, and recently acquired Caldwell Cigars (Tyler Caldwell/Caldwell Cigars? No relation, but it’s a bit funny!).  They have a great shop if you find yourself in the Myrtle Beach area.  Anyway, the cigar is called the Flamingo, has a pink band and a really nice hat if you’re a hat guy. I might have to become a hat guy, they are piling up over here.  It’s a 7″ x 38 lancero format, has an Ecuador Habano wrapper, Connecticut Broadleaf binder, and Broadleaf, Nicaraguan and Dominican in the filler. That’s a lot going on in a Lancero!  It’s made in Jonas Santana’s Blackbird factory in the DR. I like Jonas, I like his cigars, this should be a treat. If I had a complaint, it would be that it’s too short!  This is a delicious cigar, it’s bold, has some warm, savory spices, and some light floral notes in the background. I smoked a couple of these and really enjoyed them. Smoking time was around an hour and fifteen nimues, and I was careful not to oversmoke it, but it was so darned tasty I might have smoked faster than usual (puffs per hour, not overdrawing).  Jump on these when they become available later this month, all parties involved did a great job. Thanks to Tyler for allowing me to purchase cigars early! 

 

I recently received some new Macanudo cigars from the folks at General Cigar Co., and I was excited to try them.  The first one that jumped out at me was the Macanudo Emissary España Limited Edition Torpedo. I really thought the Emissary España in the robusto was a great cigar, not at all what one expects from a Macanudo. This cigar has a U.S. Connecticut Broadleaf Claro wrapper, aged 5 years, a Nicaraguan Condega binder, aged 6 years, with Dominican Piloto (aged 5 years), Colombian (aged 5 years), Nicaraguan ASP (aged 6 years), and Havana seed tobacco grown in Riolobos, Spain (aged 10 years).  The wrapper is described as Claro, but I thought it was pretty dark, not maduro dark, but not light).  The torpedo is 6″ x 52.  The Broadleaf is apparent, it’s loaded with cocoa, and I get a citrus tang. It’s a heavy cigar, recommended unless you’re expecting a Macanudo Legacy or Inspirado experience. If you don’t go stronger than than an Inspirado White, this one might be troublesome.  Great cigar, I really like it, and want to try it in a Churchill. 

 

The Macanudo Estate Reserve Flint Knoll series has eluded me until the No. 3, which means they didn’t send me No.s 1 and 2.  I wouldn’t have gone looking for these, being a non-drinker I don’t hunt down cigar with any liquor associations.  I will try them when they are presented to me, but I certainly have no frame of reference for anything alcohol related.  These aren’t flavored, of course, but have tobacco that is aged in French Oak barrels that was used for Flint Knoll’s 2021 Royal Appointment Cabernet Sauvignon. It’s offered in a beefy 7″ x 52 double corona they call a “Churchill”.  The blend is Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper, US Broadleaf binder and Brazilian, Dominican, Nicaraguan, Dominican fillers.  I only smoked one sample so far, I had a strange time with it.  Flavors were delightful, it had some sweet wood and baking spices.  Perhaps this needed to be a little bit dryer, is alternated between producing rich mouthfuls of smoke, to requiring double/triple puffs to get anything. very strange. At some point I’ll dry one down a little and give it a try, from what I could tell it was a delicious, sophisticated, medium bodied cigar.  Folks with better palates than I  rave about it. 

 

That’s all for today. I have some cool plans for this coming weekend, involving hockey, cigars, a cigar factory and a farm.  Guesses can go in the comments, maybe I’ll have a giveaway for a correct answer! Next Sunday’s post may be a little late. Until the next time,

 

CigarCraig 

 

 

Share

1 Comment

Filed under Review